Skip to content
Willard Gary Black
Courtesy of Catawba County Sheriff's Office

Fatal Shooting Reported At Business, 85-Year-Old Owner Charged (Updated at 8:26 p.m., 6/17/26)

A fatal shooting occurred at a Newton business and the owner has been charged. Shortly after 3 p.m. today (June 17), the Newton Police Department received a call in reference to a shooting that occurred at the Old Hickory Tannery on Locust Street. When officers arrived at the scene, they found a man identified as 59-year-old Robert Roger Arguelles of Taylorsville.

He was found in an office area, and he had sustained a gunshot wound to the chest and back, life-saving efforts were started but were unsuccessful and he was pronounced deceased at the scene.

The preliminary investigation indicates the male victim and a co-worker, identified as 85-year-old Willard Gary Black of Hickory had an altercation and Black shot the victim in the chest and back. The suspect was detained at the scene and the weapon used was recovered.

Black (pictured), who is listed as the founder, primary owner, and president, has been charged with second-degree-murder and will have a first appearance in Newton District Court on Thursday (June 18).

Robert Arguelles
courtesy of Alexander County Schools

The victim, Arguelles, is listed as an investor and partner. He was also a member of the Alexander County Board of Education. The investigation into this incident is ongoing. Anyone who witnessed the incident or who may be able to provide any additional information is asked to contact Investigator C. Davis with the Newton Police Department at (828) 465-7430 or cdavis@newtonnc.gov.

[Photo of Black courtesy of Catawba County Sheriff’s Office]